Lab - Project draft peer review

Lab
Modified

April 25, 2024

Important

The project peer review is due Friday, April 26 at 11:59pm.

No submission on Gradescope needed, just post issues on GitHub by this time.

In this lab, you will…

Project peer review

Each team will review two other teams’ project. As a team you should spend ~25 minutes on each team’s project.

  • Find the names of the teams whose projects you’re reviewing below. You should already have access to this team's repo.

  • Each team member should go to the repo of the team you’re reviewing.

  • Then,

    • 1-2 team members clone the team’s project and renders it to check for reproducibility. This includes both the Quarto documents (use the “Build” tab and “Render project” to render all of them simultaneously) as well as any additional materials (e.g. R scripts). Hopefully the team provides documentation so you know what to look for.

    • 1-2 team members open the team’s draft report (docs/report.pdf).

    • 1 team member opens an issue on the team’s repo using the appropriate issue template.

    • All team members discuss the project based on the prompts on the issue template and one team member records the feedback and submits the issue.

  • To open an issue in the repo you’re reviewing, click on New issue, and click on “Peer review (students)”. Fill out this issue, answering all the prompts in the form.

Review pairings

Your team name To review 1 To review 2
201
Brilliant Cassowary Brilliant Kookaburra (repo) Brilliant Koala (repo)
Brilliant Dingo Brilliant Cassowary (repo) Brilliant Kookaburra (repo)
Brilliant Emu Brilliant Dingo (repo) Brilliant Cassowary (repo)
Brilliant Kangaroo Brilliant Emu (repo) Brilliant Dingo (repo)
Brilliant Koala Brilliant Kangaroo (repo) Brilliant Emu (repo)
Brilliant Kookaburra Brilliant Koala (repo) Brilliant Kangaroo (repo)
203
Elegant Cassowary Elegant Wombat (repo) Elegant Wallaby (repo)
Elegant Echidna Elegant Cassowary (repo) Elegant Wombat (repo)
Elegant Emu Elegant Echidna (repo) Elegant Cassowary (repo)
Elegant Kangaroo Elegant Emu (repo) Elegant Echidna (repo)
Elegant Koala Elegant Kangaroo (repo) Elegant Emu (repo)
Elegant Kookaburra Elegant Koala (repo) Elegant Kangaroo (repo)
Elegant Wallaby Elegant Kookaburra (repo) Elegant Koala (repo)
Elegant Wombat Elegant Wallaby (repo) Elegant Kookaburra (repo)
204
Impressive Cassowary Impressive Wombat (repo) Impressive Wallaby (repo)
Impressive Dingo Impressive Cassowary (repo) Impressive Wombat (repo)
Impressive Echidna Impressive Dingo (repo) Impressive Cassowary (repo)
Impressive Emu Impressive Echidna (repo) Impressive Dingo (repo)
Impressive Koala Impressive Emu (repo) Impressive Echidna (repo)
Impressive Kookaburra Impressive Koala (repo) Impressive Emu (repo)
Impressive Wallaby Impressive Kookaburra (repo) Impressive Koala (repo)
Impressive Wombat Impressive Wallaby (repo) Impressive Kookaburra (repo)
206
Marvelous Cassowary Marvelous Wallaby (repo) Marvelous Kookaburra (repo)
Marvelous Dingo Marvelous Cassowary (repo) Marvelous Wallaby (repo)
Marvelous Echidna Marvelous Dingo (repo) Marvelous Cassowary (repo)
Marvelous Emu Marvelous Echidna (repo) Marvelous Dingo (repo)
Marvelous Kangaroo Marvelous Emu (repo) Marvelous Echidna (repo)
Marvelous Kookaburra Marvelous Kangaroo (repo) Marvelous Emu (repo)
Marvelous Wallaby Marvelous Kookaburra (repo) Marvelous Kangaroo (repo)
207
Phenomenal Cassowary Phenomenal Wallaby (repo) Phenomenal Kookaburra (repo)
Phenomenal Dingo Phenomenal Cassowary (repo) Phenomenal Wallaby (repo)
Phenomenal Echidna Phenomenal Dingo (repo) Phenomenal Cassowary (repo)
Phenomenal Kookaburra Phenomenal Echidna (repo) Phenomenal Dingo (repo)
Phenomenal Wallaby Phenomenal Kookaburra (repo) Phenomenal Echidna (repo)
208
Skillful Cassowary Skillful Wombat (repo) Skillful Wallaby (repo)
Skillful Dingo Skillful Cassowary (repo) Skillful Wombat (repo)
Skillful Echidna Skillful Dingo (repo) Skillful Cassowary (repo)
Skillful Kangaroo Skillful Echidna (repo) Skillful Dingo (repo)
Skillful Koala Skillful Kangaroo (repo) Skillful Echidna (repo)
Skillful Kookaburra Skillful Koala (repo) Skillful Kangaroo (repo)
Skillful Wallaby Skillful Kookaburra (repo) Skillful Koala (repo)
Skillful Wombat Skillful Wallaby (repo) Skillful Kookaburra (repo)
209
Wondrous Cassowary Wondrous Wombat (repo) Wondrous Wallaby (repo)
Wondrous Dingo Wondrous Cassowary (repo) Wondrous Wombat (repo)
Wondrous Echidna Wondrous Dingo (repo) Wondrous Cassowary (repo)
Wondrous Emu Wondrous Echidna (repo) Wondrous Dingo (repo)
Wondrous Kangaroo Wondrous Emu (repo) Wondrous Echidna (repo)
Wondrous Kookaburra Wondrous Kangaroo (repo) Wondrous Emu (repo)
Wondrous Wallaby Wondrous Kookaburra (repo) Wondrous Kangaroo (repo)
Wondrous Wombat Wondrous Wallaby (repo) Wondrous Kookaburra (repo)

Grading

Peer reviews will be graded on the extent to which it comprehensively and constructively addresses the components of the reviewee’s team’s report.

  • 0 points: No peer review

  • 1 point: Only one peer review issue open, feedback provided is not constructive or actionable

  • 2 points: Both peer review issues open, feedback provided is not constructive or actionable

  • 3 points: Both peer review issues open, feedback provided is not sufficiently thorough

  • 4 points: Both peer review issues open, one of the reviews is not sufficiently thorough

  • 5 points: Both peer review issues open, both reviews are constructive, actionable, and sufficiently thorough

Note

The feedback issue will come from one team member on GitHub since you can’t collectively edit an issue. However it must represent the opinions of the entire team. It is not a single team member’s responsibility to provide feedback, they’re just the record keeper for the team.

Acknowledgments